The Minnesota Vikings face a crucial quarterback decision as the franchise tag deadline approaches, with Sam Darnold emerging as a potential candidate despite an uneven first season with the team.
The situation is further complicated by J.J. McCarthy’s ongoing recovery from two preseason meniscus surgeries, leaving the Vikings to navigate a delicate balance as the new season draws near.
Recent reports from Jason La Canfora suggest McCarthy’s path to full recovery isn’t as straightforward as initially hoped.
The young quarterback, selected tenth overall last year, still faces “significant” physical rebuilding, according to La Canfora’s insights.
This uncertainty has apparently pushed the Vikings toward protecting their quarterback position, with sources indicating the team is reluctant to let Darnold test the free agency waters.
“I hear that J.J. McCarthy… still has significant work to do to rebuild his body, let alone adjust to the NFL,” La Canfora said.
“I hear that J.J. McCarthy… still has significant work to do to rebuild his body, let alone adjust to the NFL”, per @JasonLaCanfora 👀
LaCanfora continues, “several executives from QB needy teams, who would have at least some interest in [Sam] Darnold, suggested he’s not going… pic.twitter.com/nev10G6iKD
— The Purple Persuasion (@TPPSkol) February 14, 2025
The clock is ticking for the Vikings and Darnold to reach an agreement before March 10th, when he becomes eligible to negotiate with other teams.
From Darnold’s perspective, the free agency route could prove more lucrative, potentially leading to a long-term contract worth over $30 million annually with a quarterback-hungry team.
The Baker Mayfield precedent looms large in this scenario. Mayfield’s impressive three-year, $100 million deal with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers last offseason sets an intriguing benchmark.
However, the Vikings’ situation differs significantly from Tampa Bay’s 2024 decision, primarily due to McCarthy’s presence in the equation.
While avoiding the franchise tag’s hefty $40 million cap hit might seem appealing, McCarthy’s uncertain recovery status adds another layer of complexity to Minnesota’s quarterback puzzle.
This isn’t just about securing a starter for next season – it’s about managing risk, cap space, and the development of a first-round investment in McCarthy.
