Zak Crawley? Tom Haines? Rehan Ahmed? Who should open batting for England in Tests alongside Ben Duckett? | Cricket News


The Test match summer is edging closer.

England begin a huge nine months of red-ball cricket with a one-off game against Zimbabwe at Trent Bridge from May 22, before five fixtures at home to India and then five away in Australia as they look to win The Ashes for the first time since 2015.

So, who should open the batting for those challenges?

Ben Duckett is a shoo-in after averaging over 40 and scoring more than 2,000 runs in 28 games since returning to the team in 2022 – but his top-order partner is up for debate due to Zak Crawley’s average of 15.14 across his last 14 Test innings.

England's Ben Duckett plays a shot during the day one of third test cricket match between Pakistan and England,
Image:
Ben Duckett has become a key player for England – but who should open alongside him?

England value Crawley highly and have placed plenty of faith in him.

They have been willing to accept a lack of consistency because of what he is capable of at his best, highlighted by an average north of 40 against Australia and a sublime 189 against them during the 2023 Ashes Test at Emirates Old Trafford.

Yet there are players making a case in County Championship cricket, so perhaps the Crawley-Duckett partnership is not set in stone…

Zak Crawley

Man in possession Crawley averaged just 8.66 in New Zealand late last year, with a top-score of 21 in six innings and four single-digit dismissals, and he has only passed fifty once in his last eight Tests stretching back to last summer.

However, the batter has flourished against Australia in the past and England think he can do so again when the Ashes is held on what could very well be bouncy and true pitches this winter.

Zak Crawley, Kent and England opener
Image:
England value Zak Crawley highly but the opener has struggled for form in Test cricket of late

Crawley’s impetus at the top of the order has been a hallmark of the Bazball era to date, helping England get ahead in games even if mega individual scores have frequently eluded him.

The hierarchy are all in on Crawley and it looks unlikely that faith will wane just yet, but if his lean form continues against Zimbabwe and India, a decision may have to be made.

Tom Haines

Sussex left-hander Haines is the leading run-scorer in County Championship Division One at time of writing – 449 across three games with his two hundreds including a knock of 174 against Surrey.

We know England director of cricket Rob Key is a fan, with his last tweet before taking that role three years ago saying Haines “looks a bloody good player in my humble opinion.” The numbers back Key up as Haines’ career average is a shade under 40.

Rehan Ahmed

England's Rehan Ahmed attends a practice session, in Rawalpindi, Pakistan, Wednesday, Oct. 23, 2024. (AP Photo/Anjum Naveed)
Image:
Rehan Ahmed has started opening the batting for Leicestershire in the County Championship

This would be a maverick move but we know England are not immune to those.

Leg-spinning all-rounder Rehan has moved to the top of the order for Leicestershire this season and gone on to biff 77 from 59 balls against Derbyshire and then a 149-ball 100 against Lancashire. Attacking verve from the opening position England seem to adore.

Picking Rehan to open alongside Duckett would also allow them to get another spinner into the side – he could also be the sole spinner if Shoaib Bashir were to be preferred to another seamer – so maybe this selection would not be as out there as it seems.

Jacob Bethell

Speaking of out there picks and Bethell was very much one of those when he was called into England’s Test squad for the New Zealand series and ultimately ended up batting at No 3, despite never having scored a professional hundred.

England's Jacob Bethell bats during play on day two of the second cricket test between New Zealand and England at the Basin Reserve in Wellington, New Zealand, Saturday, Dec.7, 2024. (Kerry Marshall/Photosport via AP)
Image:
Jacob Bethell impressed at No 3 in New Zealand, so could he jump to the top of the order?

But the 21-year-old acquitted himself very well, scoring three half-centuries, including 96 in his second Test, while playing virtually as an opener. Across the three Tests, Bethell never came in later than the fifth over, so maybe opening could be in his future.

The Warwickshire man may be out of the running for the Zimbabwe Test due to his IPL stint with Royal Challengers Bengaluru and it could be that if he stays in the England XI long term that he nudges out Ollie Pope for the No 3 spot.

Ben McKinney

Durham’s McKinney, 20, is a player of real promise, scoring a century for England Lions in Australia over the winter and then amassing 153 against Warwickshire in the County Championship last week.

Ben McKinney, Durham, County Championship cricket (Getty Images)
Image:
Ben McKinney reminds Sky Sports’ Charles Dagnall of Marcus Trescothick

Speaking about the former England Under-19 captain, Sky Sports pundit Charles Dagnall said: “I know how much England like McKinney, who is tall and reminds me of Marcus Trescothick.

“His footwork is minimal but his eyes are fantastic. He is forceful, powerful and has a solid defence.”

Alex Lees

McKinney’s Durham team-mate and fellow left-hander Lees was there at the start of Bazball only to be axed by England and replaced by Duckett as Crawley’s opening partner in late 2022.

Alex Lees, Durham, County Championship (Getty Images)
Image:
Alex Lees has just scored a big hundred for Durham

Lees responded to his dropping by racking up over 1,300 runs – including five hundreds and as many fifties – in the County Championship in 2023, before making 924 runs in 2024 on his team’s return to the top flight.

This year, the 32-year-old has just notched 172 against his former county Yorkshire at a strike-rate north of 70.

Who else could be in the mix?

Three previous England openers in Haseeb Hameed (Nottinghamshire), Dom Sibley (Surrey) and Keaton Jennings (Lancashire) will hope their names are mentioned in selection meetings after decent starts to the season.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Michael Atherton and Nasser Hussain discuss whether England players who have been selected in the past should be able to come back after improving in county cricket

In fact, Sibley’s start has been more than decent with two hundreds and two half-centuries in his five innings so far, although his strike-rate of 42 may hamper his hopes of a recall.

Hameed registered innings of 92 and 138 not out in his previous two outings, while in Division Two, Jennings recorded scores of 55, 49, 96 and 49 for Lancashire before two cheap exits against Leicestershire.

England men’s Test matches this summer ☀️

All games at 11am UK and Ireland; all live on Sky Sports

  • vs Zimbabwe: Thursday May 22-Sunday May 25 – Trent Bridge
  • vs India: Friday June 20-Tuesday June 24 – Headingley
  • vs India: Wednesday July 2-Sunday July 6 – Edgbaston
  • vs India: Thursday July 10-Monday July 14 – Lord’s
  • vs India: Wednesday July 23-Sunday July 27 – Emirates Old Trafford
  • vs India: Thursday July 31-Monday August 4 – The Kia Oval

Ashes series in Australia 2025-26 🏏

All times UK and Ireland

  • First Test: Friday November 21-Tuesday November 25 (2.30am) – Optus Stadium, Perth
  • Second Test: Thursday December 4-Monday December 8 (4.30am) – The Gabba, Brisbane
  • Third Test: Wednesday December 17-Sunday December 21 (12am) – Adelaide Oval
  • Fourth Test: Thursday December 25-Monday December 29 (11.30pm) – Melbourne Cricket Ground
  • Fifth Test: Sunday January 4-Thursday January 8 (11.30pm) – Sydney Cricket Ground

More From Author

‘Allow slower work pace, flexible schedules’: Labour ministry writes to states to safeguard workers against heatwave

Competition Authority summons former Shufersal CEO to hearing

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *