When South Sydney Rabbitohs announced the signing of Lewis Dodd from St Helens, there was cautious optimism among fans. Dodd, a young English halfback with Grand Final-winning experience, was touted as a promising addition to the club’s long-term plans.
But months into the 2025 NRL season, Rabbitohs supporters are still waiting for Dodd to be given a shot in the NRL—and questions are mounting.
A Risky Recruitment Gamble
Souths handed Dodd a sizeable contract, reportedly banking on his potential to become a long-term halfback option. However, unlike other English imports such as George Williams or Sam Tomkins, Dodd didn’t arrive in Australia with the credentials of a game-breaking playmaker or a former Man of Steel winner.
In fact, he was never even seriously considered for that award, which is telling.
When you consider that players like Jackson Hastings and Brodie Croft—who struggled to find consistency in the NRL—have managed to win Man of Steel honours, Dodd’s absence from that conversation paints a stark picture. If those players are excelling in Super League and still falling short in the NRL, what chance does a player who wasn’t even among the best in England have?
Pre-Season Performance Raised Alarm Bells
Dodd’s pre-season performances, particularly in the annual Charity Shield clash, did little to inspire confidence. One moment in that game stuck out to observers and likely to coaching staff. When Valentine Holmes scooped up a loose ball and sprinted 90 metres for a try, Dodd was the closest chaser at the outset.
Yet, within 40 metres, he was overtaken by five Rabbitohs teammates—including forwards. Whether it was a lack of speed, poor fitness, or questionable desire, the visual was damning.
In the NRL, where defensive commitment and scramble effort are non-negotiables, that moment may have sealed his short-term fate.
No Buzz, No Highlights
For fans still clamouring for Dodd’s selection, ask yourself: where are the NSW Cup highlights? Why hasn’t he dominated reserve grade to the point of forcing selection?
The reality is, he hasn’t. Dodd has failed to stamp himself as a standout even at that level. If you can’t clearly outperform second-tier players, you’re not ready for the elite pace, intensity, and precision of the NRL.
Accountability in Recruitment
This situation reflects poorly on whoever within the Rabbitohs hierarchy approved such a high-risk signing without a clear transition plan or evidence he could adapt to NRL standards. For a club battling inconsistency and seeking direction, burning a valuable roster spot and salary cap space on a half not up to standard is a mistake they can’t afford.
South Sydney is a club with proud history and expectations. Fans deserve answers. Dodd might still find his footing in Australian rugby league, but as it stands, this looks like a recruitment misfire—and one that should have consequences at the decision-making level.
