The New York Knicks find themselves at a crossroads after a disappointing playoff exit.
The postseason run showcased legitimate talent capable of competing in the Eastern Conference. However, the aftermath has brought scrutiny from multiple angles.
Head coach Tom Thibodeau is facing criticism for his rotation management and perceived overuse of starters. Meanwhile, Karl-Anthony Towns has drawn notice for underwhelming performances during crucial moments.
The criticism reached new heights when New York radio host Brandon Tierney gave a pointed assessment of the franchise’s direction.
“Towns is just slow, he is sloppy and he is soft, and that’s not changing. So, the Knicks have to come to the determination. Who goes? It’s either the coach or it’s the semi-star player,” Tierney said, via WFAN Sports Radio.
.@BrandonTierney says Karl-Anthony Towns or Tom Thibodeau has gotta go: pic.twitter.com/uVZAr6EDiE
— WFAN Sports Radio (@WFAN660) June 2, 2025
Tierney’s analysis extends beyond individual performance concerns. He points to a fundamental lack of chemistry between Towns and Jalen Brunson, suggesting this disconnect undermines team cohesion.
The offensive system appears stagnant, frequently relying on isolation plays and desperation shots while depending heavily on Brunson’s brilliance.
Defensive issues compound the problems. The Knicks struggled with transition defense, exhibited poor closeout technique, and surrendered 3-point attempts at problematic rates.
These shortcomings become magnified during high-stakes games when defensive stops prove critical.
Thibodeau and Towns each represent a significant investment, yet their current trajectory suggests change may be necessary.
The Knicks must evaluate whether the coaching philosophy aligns with the roster construction or if personnel moves would better serve long-term success.
With another championship-free season in the books, the Knicks face difficult decisions that could reshape their title aspirations.
NEXT: Insider ‘Would Think Long And Hard’ About Knicks Trade For Kevin Durant
